Summer
Tutoring—The
Best and Worst of Times!
By Richard McManus
Also published in
the March 2004 Kidding
Around
Summertime provides many possibilities for
tutoring, and there are a variety of types of programs available to
parents and children to suit these needs. “Summer school” is a
traditional threat in the parents’ attempt to motivate their
children toward better performances in school. Some children face a
required summer school because of a poor academic year, and approach
it with all the enthusiasm of longtime Hingham residents regarding
the Greenbush line. Therefore private, elective summer academic
programs must provide major benefits to the child—and
be enjoyable as well.
The major summer tutoring types include:
1. Embedded in a recreation program.
2. Intensive full-time programs.
3. Intensive but distributed programs (1-3x per week).
4. Enrichment programs.
The easiest program to persuade your son or
daughter to attend is one that is included in a summer camp or
recreational activity. These programs are most frequently of the
enrichment variety—some
extra practice and support to help students improve their academic
skills during a day that is predominantly recreational. For many
children they are an ideal way to keep rust from forming on critical
skills while also getting a tan!
If your child is more than two years behind in
reading at any age you should make every effort to change the
picture. The first student at our learning center, for example, is
now well above grade level in reading and composition. Her new
confidence is worth every effort that she and her parents made. As
she entered the fourth grade she was almost three years behind in
reading. Now she is on the honor role in middle school and scored in
the 95th to 98th percentile in reading and composition. She is happy
and feels highly accomplished—and
deservedly so!
The most extreme form of summer tutoring is the
full time, full summer program. Several major tutoring chains
provide these programs, and they will happily offer you a method to
finance them as well. Prices can be stunning, but these chains offer
strong testimonial support of their work with children. These
programs can be worthwhile if they are effective with a child who
has failed to learn to read and is now nearing college age. There
are many less intensive programs that can be equally successful, but
there are some clear advantages to having the child work throughout
the summer with an intensive program—and
always keep in mind that the danger of failing to read justifies the
length and expense of such programs.
Less intensive programs can be quite successful as
well. It is quite possible to rapidly advance in reading if the
program is properly designed and delivered. If your early reader
struggles with reading, make certain that your tutor will use a
phonics-based approach. Be extremely wary of the Reading Recovery
program, as it is not a phonics program and tends to continue the
problems that began through the use of a whole language curriculum.
I would also recommend that if your child is not
succeeding in his present school setting it might be best to look
for instructional approaches that are different from those used in
his or her classroom. While one-to-one tutoring helps, the design of
the program is more important than the ratio, and continuing the
same form of instruction with a higher ratio may not lead the kinds
of dramatic improvements that are readily possible with better
instructional approaches.
Enrichment programs are primarily for children who
are at or above their grade levels in their present academic
performances. They are an excellent method for helping a child build
even stronger performances, become more skilled and fluent, or
prepare for standardized tests. These programs most often center on
a particular area but are broadly designed to increase academic and
general knowledge rather than being targeted narrowly on a specific
skill area. They can be a wonderful “extra” for the child who loves
to learn—or
can provide the enjoyment and stimulation to help a child discover
the love of learning!
Finally there is home tutoring. While not
mentioned above, there is always the possibility of using the summer
as a time for independent exploration of a series of books, or a
particular author, or some interesting point in geography or other
sciences. You don’t need to use a tutoring center! There is a world
of excellent instructional material at local libraries, online, and
through the various homeschooling resources. Even if you are not a
homeschooler, the summer can be your chance to see just how your
child is learning. Have a wonderful summer! |